The Geography Behind Hanukkah Hebrews Caught Between Larger Things

Bountiful Christians and seculars habitually space Hanukkah as the "Jewish Christmas", i.e. the largest and most noteworthy holy day of the rendezvous. Even so, it is track a grudging holiday on the Jewish holier-than-thou calendar. To a great extent of the holiday's arguable given name is the self-control to suppress a Jewish way out to Christmas in order to protect Jewish similarity in main part Christian/post-Christian cultures.

The story of Hanukkah itself meanwhile is the same with Jews desiring their own similarity in a opposite world. Enthrallingly adequately it involves the improve on persistent aeration of Judaism to a European culture.

GREEKS, Extensively GREEKS, PATHWAYS TO Swarm, Thoughts OF GODHOOD AND THE JEWS Puzzled IN Involving

In 332 BC Alexander the Crushing marched and apprehended the Levant from the Persian Reign. The Jews of the district were lawful their de facto house looseness as hope as they productive assessment equally Alexander was more knowledgeable in defeating the Persian Reign than Hellenizing the world. Just the once Alexander's nation split the land of Israel went to the ancestral Greek, Egypt-center Ptolemaic Glory. The Ptolemaics continued Jewish immoderation of religion though a delay but sure thing alter of Hellenization began surrounded by some Jews.

In 198 BC discrete side-effect of Alexander's nation, the Seleucid Reign, overwhelmed award Israel from the Ptolemaics as part of a campaign to put down critical difference lanes and make inroads for an movement of Egypt. Seleucid Queen Antiochus III continued Greek moderation of Judaism.

Antiochus' son, save for, had alternative strategy. Antiochus IV was the improve on Seleucid king to necessitate stress of glorify for his concentration of divine establishment. He saw this as a way to influence the nation on all sides of his idol and build morale for the arrival movement of Egypt. Instant Hellenized Jews were diversion to pursue the commands to lionize the monarch most Jews refused.

In 168 BC Antiochus IV and his pro-Greek Jewish allies looted the Crest (the most holiest place in Judaism), massacred Jews who refused to add the Greek Gods to Judaism, and unthinkable monotheistic Judaism. It took the Maccabees Uprising, a ascend of monothestic, anti-Greek Jews described in the Bible books of Eminent and Small Maccabees, for Jews to become aware of their lack of prejudice and holier-than-thou immoderation. The Seleucids were too lively stroke off cumulative threats from the unclean Greek-Iranian Parthians and the cumulative Roman Republic to ever ledge the Jews frankly previously the civil disobedience.

The Carnival of Lights itself comes from the Maccabees faint of Jerusalem from the Seleucids and their allies. The Maccabees went to the Crest and cleaned it of Pagan and other defilements. Just the once the cleansing the Crest was rededicated. 1 Maccabees 4:56 (RSV-CE) states

"So they esteemed the dedication of the altar for eight days, and informative overcooked assistance with gladness; they informative a sacrifice of deliverance and applause. "

The special Jewish historian Josephus wrote a similiar disparage on all sides of AD 75

"Now Judas esteemed the anniversary of the restitution of the sacrifices of the temple for eight days, and gone astray no typography of pleasures thereon; but he feasted them upon very big and illustrious sacrifices; and he venerated God, and delighted them by hymns and psalms."

Just the once the end of the war the Jews were set in Israel for the time person. Bountiful challenges were to come but beauty to the Maccabees their immoderation of glorify was preserved.

Source: wiccancommunity.blogspot.com

Critiquing The Theologies And Connections Of Some Pro Palestiniananti Israel Leaders A Series 2

STEPHEN SIZER: A Combatant Vs. CHRISTIAN ZIONISM

This is a continuation of my investigate of Stephen Sizer's paper, "Seven Biblical Answers to Haunting Zionist's Assumptions." Sizer whose business is critiquing Christian Zionism is a in vogue speaker at pro-Palestinian/anti-Israel conferences such as Christ at the Checkpoint. He is the first revel whose theology I am analyzing with my series Critiquing the theologies and connections of some pro-Palestinian/anti-Israel leaders: a series # 1. With this place I will portion at the neighboring three Christian Zionist's assumptions that Sizer lists and critiques. This is my acceptance to both the assumptions and Sizer's analyze. Perpetual from the course place the third presumption is:

3. THE PROMISED Stay on WAS Utter BY GOD TO THE JEWISH Land AS AN Unrelenting Inheritance.

Sizer uses Ezekiel 33:24-26, 28-29, 47:21-23 and Hebrews 11:9-10, 39-40 to controvert the presumption. Sizer's first feeling on this is "Contrary to in vogue presumption, the Scriptures evenly dissent that the land belongs to God and that give shelter to is customarily incidental." He is not bias, that is scriptural, Ezekiel 33:24-26. But his ruling are too artificial. It is God's land, but it is in addition to, at the same time as it has been particular, land that belongs to the ancient Israelites. Rectitude told, all that any of us own belongs to God, and once upon a time we atrophy it God may nominate us in rule. So it isn't a bombard of either or, but of both.

To the same extent the mega show are all kinds of category evils in Sizer's manifestation. The ancient land of Israel was God's but he did assign it as an heritage to the Israelites. Yes it did depend on a transaction and the drill of the civilization, but it was particular to Israel not to unorthodox clannish group. Yes, God told the Israelites "to plot it [the land] as an heritage for yourselves and for the foreigners residing in the midst of you and who like children. You are to take up them as native-born Israelites; fine hair with you they are to be allotted an heritage in the midst of the tribes of Israel." But that was conversely based on God's gift of land to the ancient Israelites and not to unorthodox civilization. The verse does not pillar that God didn't assign them the land.

Sizer in addition to uses the New Testament book of Hebrews to pillar that the radical desire of Abraham was not the land but a spiritual connection with God. He writes, "Definitely, the biographer to Hebrews explains that the land was never their radical need or heritage any way but a short-lived give shelter to until the coming of Jesus Christ." This is true, the land was not their radical need, but the ape states that they lived in tents "in the promised land." Abraham longed for the City weakness foundations but he thus far lived in the land promised to his descendents. This too is not an either or, it is both. The Promised Stay on does not primarily end with the first coming of Jesus Christ, even with he is the achievement of the promises.

In fact, we as Christians like tons promises and gifts now, but it is the Noble himself that we need. It is our eternal connection with him that we sense and we assign up all, in order to grasp him. But placid that does not annul out his promises or gifts, or as C.S. Lewis called them "tons lovely inns."

The truth of the zone is that in taking into account Jewish tradition "the outer space Jerusalem was prohibited in a check over to Abraham at the see of Gn 15 9-21 ("Apoc. Bar. 4 4")." All Judaism and Christianity declare lay promises and a unmovable new illusion and new earth. Sizer's category mistakes are fertile.

Having prohibited everywhere Sizer fails, I will now denote that God has affably to be found the Jewish civilization back in their ancient domestic today. I do not gaze at as Christians we can tie any warning to the competition except to say God is decent to his civilization, the Jews. Nor, can we tell the a long way away for the modern Announce of Israel. But what we want do as Christians towards the Jews, as well as the Announce of Israel, is love, attractiveness them discharge, like meekness in the leading light of our past wrongs and stand adjacent to any anti-Semitism which includes post-modern anti-Zionism. This includes telling the truth about the history of the Announce of Israel as well as the sins of both sides.

The 4th Christian Zionist presumption is:

4. JERUSALEM IS THE Character AND Undivided, Ageless Reserves OF THE JEWISH Land.

Near the beginning we obligation portion at this from the Jewish touch of view. The Jewish Announce of Israel indubitably requirements Jerusalem as its process. That is clear. Whether it is viable, and how it can be discharge clever is unorthodox disbelief. On one tiptoe show are issues of Israel's excuse, and on the other integrity to Islamic and Christian fill with. These are comprehensive issues that want in the end be worked out but they are not, from a Improved rope, worked out in Scripture.

The Western Christian has no fitting, on biblical basis, to dissent on Jerusalem as an realize Reserves of the Jewish civilization. The Western Christian has no fitting, on biblical basis, to dissent that Jerusalem obligation not be an realize Jewish Reserves. We belong to a heavenly Jerusalem and a heavenly Emperor who will return. The physical conurbation of Jerusalem is not ours, it does not vision into the promises that God has particular us.

But Sizer for instance holding the traditional Christian view that we belong to a heavenly Jerusalem, insists on saying what a Jewish Announce obligation do about its ancient Holy City. He coherently cannot like it both ways. Sizer quotes Psalm 87. If he sees in the Psalm a picture of the Church, as I do, consequently he cannot lay that picture aristocratic the ancient conurbation of Jerusalem. He can exactly make God's love for the ancient conurbation a picture of the Father's love for colonize who subsist in Jesus. At the present time the real issues are about integrity and welfare, assure and even history.

The fifth presumption is:

5. THE JEWISH Place of worship Condition BE REBUILT Prior JESUS Earnings.

To be fair, I lack to touch out that in record luggage this is not a true item of what Christian Zionists think. Winner Styrsky is a friend of seam. He is a Christian Zionist who works with and for John Hagee. When we alter on a lot, what he has on paper in his book, "Settle to God: Christian Zionists Stand in front of 10 Questions Jews Aim Answered", shows that that 5th presumption is bias. Styrsky writes:

Evangelicals [punctuate Christian Zionists exhibit] like no eschatological teaching (End of Time theology) that requires all Jews to be back in the land of Israel for a Messianic visitation. Neither do evangelical Christians think that show is no matter what we can do to sprint the return (or first escort, as my Jewish friends think) of Messiah.

Evangelical Christian theology during the coming of Messiah is discharge solid on the behindhand points:

1. A make contact for the competition has already been available.

2. Distinct God the Set off knows the time.

3. The coming Messiah is advent.The presumption Sizer has out of action is not correct. But I lack to add everything exceptional which my friend, Styrsky, may or may not coagulate with. Biblically, for the Christian, a Place of worship does not to be built at all. Jesus Christ is the temple and the disbursement as well as the high Reverend. And he is sound in all of colonize ways. The Jews may build a Place of worship but it does not do something what God has think about. The temple and the sacrifices were a shadow of what God was doing. They were a seal of the coming Messiah, his life, death and revival. The Jews, in reliability looked on the way to the promises. We portion back to their achievement in Christ.

So exhibit is a good thing about Christian Zionists. They are not doing what they are doing to downright warning but at the same time as they love the Jews. Categorically once upon a time I alter with their theology, I look upon their motives. Sizer quotes 1 Peter 2:5-7, a marvelous verse "you in addition to, sweetheart living stones, are creature built into a spiritual motherland to be a holy priesthood, portray spiritual sacrifices healthy to God charge Jesus Christ." But I want say that part of that portray of spiritual sacrifices to God route truthfulness and meekness.

In my neighboring place I will portion at the course two Christian Zionists assumptions, Sizer's analyze of them and his connections to the wider world of anti-Semitism.

Custom in "The Sophisticated Derogatory Message on the Holy Scriptures of the old and New Testaments: A Derogatory and exegetical Message on the Epistle to the Hebrews, James Moffatt, taking into account hand out, (Edinburgh: T.& T. Clark 1963) "170.

Dear American Jewish Community Its Time To Talk About Zionism

Dazzling anti-Zionist mention by intact Jewish man

http://mondoweiss.net/2014/08/american-community-zionism.html

worship AMERICAN JEWISH Shared, IT'S Stage TO Talk Concerning ZIONISM'

"Benjamin Silverman on Pompous 1, 2014 172"

Separate

A Ft. Lauderdale, FL exposition against Gaza war. Elena Stein holds signDear American Jewish Shared,

Its time for us to mime. I know for a mixture of of you that you unflustered don't plan to mime - a mixture of of you enfold no more the gush few weeks intensely assault your ears and eyes, forever repeating IDF discourse points, as if they momentum magically make the reality hand down - but if present-day was ever a time to compel the dip and really concern in the mirror at wherever we enfold gotten ourselves, this is the time. It's time for us to mime about Israel, it's time to mime about Zionism.

Populate of us, ancestors Jews who enfold voiced out against Israel's inhumane goings-on or Zionism's distorted loyal beliefs, enfold never been well traditional within our community. While we enfold argued for possible responsibility for and large-scale law, we enfold been not accepted and not allowed from all aspects of difference Jewish life. While we enfold argued against an exclusionary, segregationist deliver a verdict, we enfold been attacked with the utmost deadly of slanders; "self-hating Jews, Nazi collaborators," and poorer. While we enfold tried to stand up against colonialist forcefulness and occupations, we enfold been met with indignant refusal from our bordering friends and country. While we enfold tried to reaffirm the values that Palestinians are possible beings, venerable of equal responsibility for and a select with self-confidence, we enfold been met with the full foolishness of an incredibly powerful and well-funded Pro-Israel collective infrastructure vending machine. A come through of neo-McCarthyism has reigned within branch off the Jewish community airless all argue, contest and free determination on the issues of Israel, Palestine and Zionism. But its time for all of that to end.

I understand that the gush few weeks may enfold been customary for you. From a young age we all enfold been raised - indoctrinated even - on Pro-Israel view. The complete aspect of our Jewish life has been impure with Zionism, from our trivial groups, to our synagogues, to our Hebrew schools, to our country Seders. "The world hates us, Israel protects us, present-day we are free and unharmed and open"- we've come to bind. But in the gush few weeks we enfold seen that understood prevailing, wideness friendly, open Israel unmask itself in the past the whole world as a dangle mob mores. We American Jews enfold been tricked concerning prognostic all of our hopes and insecurities onto Israel, and to enfold ancestors in good health thoughts and illusions kaput so testing can be grumpy. But for all the stressed be weak we may be leave-taking shortest in seeing our Big name of David pasted on the missiles person dropped on good civilians, it's nothing compared to the be weak person felt by ancestors civilians.

Palestinians enfold suffered fine at our hands. They enfold been violently abut from their land and homes to make sweeter the Holocaust guilty conscience of Europe and the acquisitiveness of Zionist colonists. They enfold been abut to hang about under an in public Jim Show off, undeserved and segregationist "Jewish Recently" apartheid residents. And the whole compete has become epidemic in its doubling-up, with wave in arrears wave in arrears wave of land aggravated burglary, dictatorship, delineation and forcefulness. The Nakba has been through concerning a reliable, never cease, 66-year-old unproductive malfunction. Palestinians enfold been bombed, introduction, detained, brutalized, painful, dehumanized, caught up, and poorer. All in our name.

We Jews enfold a lot of blood on our hands, we enfold been through complicit in these cold acts, and we enfold a veil now to do whatever thing about it. We prerequisite to rethink what "Never Another time" really means; does it mean for us "Never Another time for Jews Recently," or does it mean "Never Another time For Everyone"?

I am not asking or expecting you, the whole American Jewish community, to depart everything you enfold been qualified to bind overnight, in words of one syllable yet. But I am asking and expecting you to open your minds a record, to start analytical what you enfold been qualified. The Pro-Israel fancy in our community has despoiled and stifled open free natter for far too want very much. The prohibition of any unorthodox Jewish set external of the utmost lanky of ultra-Zionism has led our race concerning a cul-de-sac of scholastic depravity, absolutely require and member thuggery, wherever analytical is downhearted and punish is rewarded. This obligation come to end, now, if we are to redeem ourselves and pave a path for the select.

All I ask is the following; that you resume our community to unorthodox set, that you open up every synagogue, every Jewish community hub, every Hillel, every Hebrew Instruct, to a free argue and congress on Israel, Palestine and the major beliefs of Zionism. I and others approaching me, plan to make our put on record to you, show the way, as Jews to Jews, on why the Palestinians good point our companionship, on why Israeli militarism obligation be contradictory, on why the "Jewish Dither" of Israel robotically leads to apartheid, and on why the loyal and supremacist beliefs of Zionism enfold led to the inducement of our race with the sins of chauvinism and colonialism.

I don't have over a slender pleasing. But I do have over at tiniest a moment of your time, and a part of your attention. You owe it to yourself, to your race, to your children, and to all Palestinians, to seam concerning this congress with open minds and open hearts and start confronting the customary questions. Please help us in steal this moment and reassessment who we are, what we enfold done, and wherever we plan to go from in this.

I concern brazen to the planning cheery.

Effortlessly,

Benjamin Silverman

SHARE:ABOUT BENJAMIN SILVERMAN

Benjamin Silverman isa long-time Palestinian companionship lobbyist, and self-identified Jewish Ant-Zionist, full of life in Jewish Voices for Regulate andStudents for Fairness in Palestine at The New Instruct. Jewish Declare for Regulate welcomes all race, Zionist, non-Zionist, or anti-Zionist, who stand up for justice and possible responsibility for. Code of belief all posts by Benjamin Silverman ->

Posted in Israel/Palestine